retailinsidermerchandising

How Beauty Retail Buyers Choose Cleansers: An Insider Look from a Newly Promoted MD

UUnknown

2026-02-17

11 min read

Insider view of how premium retailers (inspired by Liberty’s 2026 promotion) pick cleansers — and how brands and shoppers win with footfall, margin & sustainability.

Why you care: the cleanser aisle isn’t just about foam — it’s about footfall, margin and values

If you’ve ever stood in front of a luxury beauty counter wondering why your favourite gentle gel didn’t make the premium shelf, you’re experiencing a common frustration. Shoppers want clarity: which cleansers actually belong in premium stores, where to find the best deals, and how retailers decide what to stock. Brands want a fair shot to earn space. Retail buyers want products that move and match a store’s story.

In January 2026 Liberty promoted its group buying and merchandising director to managing director of retail — a reminder that decisions at the top affect everything from shelf curation to seasonal promotions. This article is written from the viewpoint of a newly promoted managing director in premium retail (inspired by Liberty’s 2026 promotion) and gives an insider look at how modern retail buying works for cleansers. Expect practical takeaways for both beauty shoppers and brands aiming for premium shelf space.

The big three priorities shaping cleanser assortments in 2026

Three metrics consistently drive what ends up on premium shelves today: footfall, margin and sustainability. Buyers balance these against curation and brand fit to craft an assortment that tells a consistent story.

1. Footfall: products that pull people through the door (and keep them)

In 2026, physical retail is about experiences that digital alone can't replicate. A cleanser that can be demoed in-store, tied to a in-store skin diagnostics or a limited in-person masterclass increases footfall more than an equivalent online-only SKU. Buyers evaluate:

Traffic lift potential — Will this launch bring new or repeat customers to the store?
Event or activation suitability — Can we host sampling, consultations or mini-ritual experiences that create dwell time?
Cross-sell capability — Does the cleanser lead to add-on sales (toner, serum, tools)?

Example: A brand that offers in-store skin diagnostics and a timed demo has a better chance of placement because those activations increase conversion and average basket value (ABV).

2. Margin: where the numbers meet merchandising desire

Margins are the hard currency of buying. A beautifully formulated cleanser that doesn’t deliver margin or sell-through will be pulled. Buyers run scenario models covering:

Gross margin after trade discounts and promotional allowances
Sell-through rate expectations (units per week/month)
Markdown risk and lifecycle planning (limited editions vs evergreen SKUs)

In practice, brands that offer compelling launch economics (introductory margin support, co-op marketing, and a clear replenishment plan) win priority placement. High-margin, low-turn SKUs may be fine as exclusives; high-turn, lower-margin SKUs need scale and velocity.

3. Sustainability: proof matters more than positioning

By late 2025 and into 2026, shoppers and retailers expect tangible sustainability evidence. Labels alone won’t do it. Buyers evaluate:

Certification and auditability (refill partnerships, recycled content, third-party verification)
Supply chain transparency — Can the brand prove ingredient sourcing, carbon impact and waste reduction?
Retail fit — Does the brand complement existing sustainability initiatives (e.g., refill stations, circular packaging programs)?

Brands that can demonstrate measurable outcomes (reduced plastic kg/year, refill uptake rates, lifecycle assessments) significantly increase their chance of long-term placement.

"Liberty has promoted group buying and merchandising director Lydia King as managing director of retail, with the role taking effect immediately." — Retail Gazette, Jan 2026

How category management and curation decide the cleanser assortment

Category management turns macro priorities into a product mix that makes sense for both the retailer and the shopper. In premium retail, curation is part art and part math.

Category roles: hero, core, value, and discovery

We divide cleanser SKUs into roles to control space and expectations:

Hero — High-profile launches or prestige brands that define the counter and drive PR.
Core — Reliable sellers that keep units moving day after day.
Value — Entry points that broaden reach (often travel sizes or affordable clean formulas).
Discovery — Indie or niche brands that signal innovation and attract early adopters.

Mixing these roles prevents category stagnation. A well-curated cleanser bay usually has 60–70% core, 10–20% hero, 10% discovery and the remainder value-oriented stock — though exact splits vary by retailer strategy.

Assortment size and SKU rationalization

Buyers use SKU rationalization to avoid dilution. Factors that trigger rationalization include low sell-through, excessive returns, and overlapping claims (two glycolic cleansers that compete directly are inefficient). In 2026, AI-assisted assortment tools are increasingly used to model SKU cannibalization and optimize shelf layouts in real time.

Deals, promotions and pricing strategies that move cleansers

Promotions are where merchant strategy and pricing architecture meet. In premium retail, the right promotion can elevate a cleanser from niche to staple.

Popular promotional formats in 2026

Loyalty-tiered offers — Early access or bonus points for members drives repeat purchases.
Bundle economics — Cleanser + toner/serum combos increase ABV and allow higher effective margin across SKUs.
Exclusives and limited editions — Short-run formulas or packaging that are store-only create urgency and PR moments.
Event-linked promotions — Cleanser launches tied to in-store rituals, dermatology talks or holiday activations (e.g., Dry January skin detox campaigns) that create context and lift conversion.

For brands, the best approach is to design a promotional calendar with clear KPIs: uplift %, incremental sales, and loyalty acquisitions. For shoppers, time purchases to loyalty events and exclusive drops to get the best value.

Trade terms: what buyers ask for

Expect these to be negotiated during pitching:

Case discounts and introductory allowances to support initial displays.
Marketing co-investment for PR, digital ads and events.
Retail exclusivity windows for product or pack variants that justify marketing support and premium placement.
Return and replenishment terms that manage risk for both parties.

Brands that are flexible on promotional tie-ins and provide data-backed forecasts get better terms.

Omnichannel realities: how online and in-store influence buying strategy

Premium retailers operate in a blended world. Online performance influences in-store decisions and vice versa. Key signals buyers watch:

Conversion rates online — A cleanser that converts on-site is likely to perform in-store if it supports experiences.
Loyalty analytics — Repeat purchase rates, churn and CLV (customer lifetime value) guide replenishment and promotion planning.
Fulfillment reliability — Brands need robust logistics for click-and-collect and in-store returns; operational friction kills relationships quickly.

In 2026, new tools let merchants create dynamic replenishment rules by channel; that means a cleanser can be stocked as an in-store hero but limited online, or vice versa, depending on performance data.

Case study: How a mid-priced cleanser earned a spot on the premium shelf

Here’s a practical case study to show how theory becomes practice. The brand — which we’ll call CleanStart — wanted to enter premium multi-brand stores with a 150ml gentle gel cleanser.

Positioning and proof: CleanStart supplied clinical data on irritation-free results and third-party sustainability verification for 60% post-consumer recycled (PCR) packaging.
Launch economics: They offered a 10-week introductory margin support and a 12-week exclusive window for a limited-edition jar variant.
In-store activation: CleanStart funded skin-scan stations for week-one demos and provided trained beauty advisors.
Omnichannel plan: A matched online campaign with shoppable videos and AR try-on boosted digital conversion and provided the buyer with performance forecasts.
Outcome: Solid sell-through in the first six weeks, high loyalty sign-ups from demos and a permanent space in the core shelf after the exclusive ended.

Takeaway: buyers reward brands that solve three problems simultaneously — they drive footfall, protect margin, and align with sustainability goals.

Actionable advice for brands: how to get curated into premium retail

If you’re a brand owner pitching to premium retailers in 2026, here’s a checklist based on buyer priorities:

Bring measurable proof — clinical results, sustainability claims with certifications, and supply chain transparency tools.
Design an activation plan — demos, trained staff, skin diagnostics or in-store events that justify the SKU.
Offer SMART launch economics — clear, time-bound margin support, marketing co-op, and limited exclusivity options.
Prepare omnichannel content — high-quality imagery, tutorial videos and AR assets that the retailer can repurpose.
Know your category role — be explicit about whether you’re a hero, core, value or discovery SKU and pitch your expected sell-through.
Show operational readiness — reliable lead times, batch traceability and a returns plan reduce buyer risk.

Actionable advice for shoppers: where to buy cleansers and how to find the best deals

As a shopper seeking the best cleanser in premium retail, you can be strategic. Here’s how to save time and money in 2026:

Use loyalty windows: Sign up for store loyalty programs for early access and bonus points during curated beauty events.
Watch for exclusives: Premium stores often run exclusive lines or limited-edition packs that include deluxe samples — these can be higher value than straight discounts.
Bundle to increase savings: Look for curated rituals that combine cleanser + toner or tools; bundles often yield a better effective price-per-SKU.
Time purchases with in-store activations: Event weeks with demos not only let you test products but often include event-only perks like free consultations or samples.
Compare true value: Don’t just compare price tags. Factor in travel size freebies, loyalty points, and return policies when choosing where to buy.

2026 trends and future predictions that will change how cleansers are merchandised

Looking ahead, these developments will reshape buying strategy and shelf composition:

AI-driven curation — predictive models will recommend SKU changes at hyper-local levels based on footfall and online behaviour.
Refill and circular models scale — retailers that invest in in-store refill stations or take-back schemes will prioritise compatible brands.
Micro-collections and collaborations — limited-run co-brands with influencers or wellness experts will create frequent rotation and urgency.
Shoppable experiences — AR mirrors and in-aisle QR activations will convert discovery into immediate purchase more efficiently.
Dynamic pricing linked to inventory and demand — expect more targeted promotions based on loyalty tier and local demand signals.

These trends mean brands must plan for agility and continuous data transparency. Retailers will reward partners who can move fast and prove impact.

Common mistakes that lose shelf space

Retail buyers see recurring errors that sink otherwise great products. Avoid these:

No demonstrable proof — unsupported claims on irritation, sustainability or efficacy are immediate red flags.
Poor promotional planning — expecting a product to perform without launch support is unrealistic.
Operational fragility — single-source manufacturing or unstable lead times create real risk for buyers.
Overcomplicated ranges — too many SKUs with small variations dilute visibility and increase risk of poor sell-through.

Final takeaways: what matters most to buyers in 2026

When you distil buyer priorities down, three things matter most:

Does the cleanser move people into the store or online experience?
Can it deliver sustainable margin over time?
Is the brand transparent and operationally reliable?

Brands that align product innovation with measurable business outcomes and a clear sustainability story will get noticed. Shoppers who align purchases with retailer loyalty events and experience-driven activations will get the best value.

Get the checklist: how to pitch or purchase like a pro

Want a quick, actionable checklist? Here’s a compact version you can use today:

Prepare clinical or consumer proof and sustainability documentation.
Create a 90-day launch plan with demo ideas and marketing touchpoints.
Map expected sell-through and margin scenarios for the buyer.
Ensure omnichannel assets (video, AR, high-res imagery) are ready.
Be ready to support an exclusive or limited edition for launch.

Call to action

If you’re a brand ready to pitch to premium retailers or a shopper hunting the best cleanser deals, start with our curated 2026 checklist and monthly insights. Sign up for our insider brief to get real-world templates for buyer decks, a printable pitch checklist, and the latest on promotions and loyalty windows — tailored for the premium cleanser category.

Whether you’re trying to earn shelf space or pick the best value cleanser on the luxury floor, understanding how merchandising, buying strategy and curation work will save time, improve outcomes and reduce risk. Ready to act? Download the checklist, plan your launch, or join our next live briefing for brands and shoppers.

Unknown

Contributor

Senior editor and content strategist. Writing about technology, design, and the future of digital media. Follow along for deep dives into the industry's moving parts.